Alkaline Diet, Alkaline Water, and Cancer: Myth vs. Science

In recent years, the internet has exploded with claims that an alkaline diet, often supplemented with alkaline water, can prevent or even cure cancer. This idea, though well-meaning, is a misconception that overlooks the complexities of the body’s pH regulation system and cancer biology. While diet and nutrition are indeed crucial for health and cancer care, it’s essential to understand why an alkaline diet does not directly impact cancer.

QUICK REFERENCE

• Understanding the Body’s pH System: Intelligent Regulation and Homeostasis
• pH Levels Across the Body: How the Body’s pH Changes and Why It Matters in Cancer Care
• The Science of Cancer Metabolism and Acid Production
• So, Why Does This Myth Persist?
• Real Integrative Approaches to Support Cancer Care
• Discussion

Understanding the Body’s pH System: Intelligent Regulation and Homeostasis

The body’s ability to maintain a stable internal pH, known as pH homeostasis, is a cornerstone of human health. This finely tuned system ensures that the pH of the blood and extracellular fluids remains within a narrow range of 7.35 to 7.45, a requirement for critical enzymatic reactions, cellular respiration, and metabolic processes. Any deviation outside this range, even by a small margin, can lead to serious health issues such as acidosis or alkalosis, both of which can impair oxygen delivery, disrupt cardiovascular function, and hinder immune responses. (1)

The body achieves this balance through three primary mechanisms (2):

• Buffer Systems - the body’s first line of defense in maintaining pH homeostasis. The most critical is the bicarbonate buffer system, which neutralizes excess acids or bases and stabilizes blood pH by reacting with excess hydrogen ions (H⁺) or hydroxide ions (OH⁻). When acids accumulate, bicarbonate (HCO₃⁻) binds with hydrogen ions to form carbonic acid (H₂CO₃), which quickly dissociates into water (H₂O) and carbon dioxide (CO₂). Conversely, carbonic acid releases hydrogen ions to restore balance when the blood becomes too basic. This rapid response is essential for neutralizing pH changes from metabolic processes and maintaining cellular function.
• Respiratory Regulation - respiration plays a pivotal role in pH homeostasis by controlling carbon dioxide levels in the blood, a key determinant of acidity. Through normal breathing, CO₂, a byproduct of cellular metabolism, dissolves in blood plasma to form carbonic acid, which dissociates into hydrogen ions and bicarbonate. When blood becomes too acidic, the respiratory rate increases to expel more CO₂, reducing acid levels. Conversely, slower breathing retains CO₂ to address alkalinity. This mechanism allows for near-immediate adjustments to pH, making the lungs an essential regulator of acid-base balance.
• Renal Regulation - the kidneys regulate long-term pH by excreting hydrogen ions and reabsorbing bicarbonate from the blood. This process occurs in the nephron, the kidney’s functional unit, where specialized cells detect pH changes and respond accordingly. When blood becomes too acidic, the kidneys secrete hydrogen ions into urine and conserve bicarbonate, effectively neutralizing excess acid. If alkalinity is the issue, bicarbonate excretion increases to restore balance. Though slower than buffer systems and respiratory adjustments, renal regulation offers sustained control over pH, which is crucial for managing chronic conditions and maintaining overall homeostasis.

Together, these systems keep your body's pH stable and functional despite fluctuations in your diet or environment. This tight regulation underscores why dietary pH, whether acidic or alkaline, has a negligible impact on systemic pH. So, while eating an acidic or alkaline food might affect the pH of your stomach or urine, it won’t significantly alter the overall pH balance in your blood or tissues. Understanding this robust mechanism reinforces the importance of focusing on supportive cancer care strategies rather than attempting to manipulate pH through diet.

Again, despite claims that alkaline diets can cure or prevent cancer, the body’s pH regulation systems ensure that dietary changes do not significantly affect blood pH.

pH Levels Across the Body: How the Body’s pH Changes and Why It Matters in Cancer Care

In addition to blood pH, let’s deepen our understanding of the body’s sophisticated and compartmentalized pH system. This system is highly localized and tailored to the needs of each organ and function, ensuring that essential biochemical processes occur efficiently in their designated environments.

Let’s look at these systems and explore their relevance to cancer care, particularly when undergoing treatments like chemotherapy and radiation.

Oral Cavity: pH 6.8 - 7.5

The oral cavity typically ranges from slightly acidic to neutral, a balance crucial for oral health. Beneficial bacteria thrive in this environment, helping prevent infections and maintaining a healthy microbiome.

Saliva contains bicarbonate ions (HCO₃⁻), which can react with hydrogen ions (H⁺) from acids to form water and carbon dioxide, reducing acidity. It plays a pivotal role in buffering acids in the mouth, which can originate from food (citrus, soda), bacterial metabolism (acids created from bacterial breakdown of sugars), or conditions like acid reflux. Saliva also dilutes acids and washes away food particles and bacteria. These processes neutralize the oral environment to protect teeth, gums, and other tissues. This salivary buffering action and regular dental hygiene are essential for preserving oral health - a crucial aspect of the localized pH regulation in our mouths. (3)

Relevance in Cancer Care:

• Chemotherapy and radiation can cause dry mouth (xerostomia), disrupting this delicate balance and leading to a higher risk of oral infections or sores.
• Maintaining hydration and using oral care products that support a neutral pH can help mitigate these side effects.

Stomach: pH 1.5 - 2.0

The stomach’s highly acidic environment is necessary for breaking down proteins via the enzyme pepsin, absorbing essential nutrients such as iron and calcium, and killing harmful pathogens and bacteria ingested with food. (4)

The stomach's acidic environment is primarily controlled by hydrochloric acid (HCl) secretion from specialized cells in the stomach lining called parietal cells. These cells are located in the gastric glands. They are stimulated by signals such as gastrin (a hormone), histamine, and acetylcholine, which activate proton pumps to release hydrogen ions into the stomach. This process results in a highly acidic pH, optimal for breaking down food, denaturing proteins, and activating digestive enzymes.

However, the stomach’s powerful acid must be carefully balanced to prevent self-damage. To achieve this, mucus-producing cells, known as foveolar cells, secrete a thick, gel-like layer of mucus that coats the stomach lining. This mucus layer contains bicarbonate ions (HCO₃⁻), which neutralize acid at the epithelial surface, creating a pH gradient that protects the stomach lining from the corrosive effects of HCl. This protective mechanism is often referred to as the gastric mucosal barrier.

Relevance in Cancer Care:

• Certain medications or chemotherapies can weaken the mucosal barrier, making the stomach lining more susceptible to damage and increasing the chance of uncomfortable side effects like nausea and vomiting. These treatments can also disrupt stomach acid production, leading to digestive issues or nutrient deficiencies.
• Proton pump inhibitors (PPIs), often prescribed to manage reflux during treatment, can alter the stomach’s natural acidity. While beneficial in the short term, long-term use might impair nutrient absorption.

Duodenum (First Part of the Small Intestine): pH 5.6 - 8.0

As food passes from the stomach, the duodenum transitions from a mildly acidic to a slightly alkaline environment. Key processes at this point in digestion include neutralizing stomach acid with bicarbonate secreted by the pancreas, supporting the activity of pancreatic enzymes, and supporting adequate bile production for breaking down fats, proteins, and carbohydrates.

As acidic chyme, partially digested food mixed with stomach acid, exits the stomach and enters the duodenum, the body initiates a crucial buffering response to neutralize its acidity. This process is vital because the highly acidic chyme (with a pH of around 1.5 to 2.0) could damage the delicate mucosal lining of the small intestine and impair the enzymatic processes required for nutrient absorption. To counteract this, the pancreas and the duodenum secrete bicarbonate (HCO₃⁻), which reacts with hydrogen ions (H⁺) in the chyme to raise its pH to a more alkaline range. This adjustment creates an environment conducive to digestion and protects the intestinal lining.

Both mechanical and hormonal signals tightly regulate bicarbonate secretion. When chyme enters the duodenum, it triggers the release of the hormone secretin from the epithelial cells of the duodenal lining. (5) Secretin acts on the pancreas, stimulating its ductal cells to release a bicarbonate-rich fluid into the duodenum via the pancreatic ducts. Additionally, bile from the liver, stored in the gallbladder, is released into the duodenum, and its alkaline pH of 7.6 to 8.8 contributes to this buffering effect.

The neutralization of chyme serves multiple critical functions. It activates digestive enzymes, like pancreatic amylase and lipase, which require a near-neutral pH to function effectively and break down carbohydrates, fats, and proteins. It also protects the intestinal lining, the bicarbonate ion-enriched mucus layer in the duodenum that forms a protective barrier against acid-induced damage and ulcers. The less acidic environment also facilitates nutrient absorption.

Relevance for Cancer Care:

• Chemotherapy and radiation can impair the pancreas and liver or alter gut function, leading to decreased bicarbonate secretion, impaired bile and enzyme production, and an increased risk of acid-related damage in the small intestine.
• Effective digestion in the duodenum ensures proper nutrient absorption, critical for maintaining strength and supporting immune function during treatment.

Small Intestine: pH 7.2 - 7.5

The small intestine’s slightly neutral pH allows for carbohydrates, proteins, and fats to be broken down into simpler molecules for absorption into the bloodstream and protects the delicate mucosal lining.

After the significant elevation of the chyme's pH in the duodenum, the intestinal glands, or the crypts of Lieberkühn, located in the duodenal and jejunal lining, also contribute to pH regulation by secreting an alkaline mucus containing bicarbonate ions. This mucus forms a protective layer over the epithelial lining, shielding it from the corrosive effects of gastric acid and digestive enzymes while further buffering the acidic chyme.

Relevance for Cancer Care:

• Cancer treatments can damage pancreatic cells, reduce bicarbonate secretion, and cause inflammation in the intestines, leading to digestive discomfort and diarrhea, nutrient malabsorption, and increased susceptibility to acid-induced injury.
• Certain cancers, like colorectal cancer, may disrupt the pH and microbiome of the small intestine.

Proximal Colon ( Beginning of the Large Intestine): pH 5.5-6.5

The gut microbiota, a diverse community of trillions of microorganisms residing in the gastrointestinal tract, plays an integral role in maintaining pH balance, particularly in the colon. One of its primary mechanisms for regulating pH is the fermentation of dietary fibers into short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs). Dietary fibers found abundantly in plant-based foods such as vegetables, legumes, nuts, seeds, and fruits (largely undigested) and pass through the stomach and small intestine. Upon reaching the colon, they serve as a substrate for gut bacteria, which ferment the fibers and break them into SCFAs. (6)

Through this fermentation process, SCFAs, including acetate, propionate, and butyrate, are released into the colon, where they perform multiple roles, including pH regulation to promote microbial diversity and healthy intestinal function, which includes supporting the immune system, enhancing the absorption of certain nutrients, and facilitating water absorption and the formation of solid waste. The production of these fatty acids slightly acidifies the colon, creating a localized environment conducive to the growth of beneficial microbes while inhibiting harmful pathogens.

Distal colon (end of the large intestine): pH 7.9 - 8.5

As food residues and waste materials move through the digestive tract into the distal colon (the descending colon and rectum), the environment distinctly differs from the proximal colon due to several physiological changes. When the contents reach the distal colon, fermentable substrates are primarily depleted, significantly reducing SCFA production. Since these SCFAs are acidic, their reduced presence leads to a more neutral or alkaline pH shift.

In addition to that, specialized cells in the intestinal lining secrete bicarbonate ions (HCO₃⁻) to counteract any residual acidity from SCFAs or other acidic byproducts. The bicarbonate acts as a natural buffer, reacting with hydrogen ions (H⁺) to form water (H₂O) and carbon dioxide (CO₂), thereby raising the pH. This neutralization process is vital for protecting the more delicate tissues in the distal colon and rectum from acidic irritation, maintaining the function of local gut microbiota species that prefer alkaline conditions, and facilitating the passage of waste material through the rectum and anus without causing irritation or inflammation. (6)

The distal colon is a significant site for absorbing water, electrolytes, and nutrients. Bicarbonate secretion often accompanies chloride ion absorption, which helps maintain electrolyte balance while simultaneously modulating pH levels.

Relevance for Cancer Care:

• Maintaining a balanced gut microbiota is crucial for cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy or radiation. Treatment can disrupt gut bacteria, reducing SCFA production and altering pH, which may lead to inflammation and digestive issues. A fiber-rich diet supports SCFA production, helping preserve gut pH and promote intestinal health.
• SCFAs like butyrate, produced through fiber fermentation, have anti-inflammatory effects and strengthen the gut lining. This effect is particularly beneficial, helping to protect against treatment-related side effects and supporting overall gut function.
• Disruptions in colon pH and microbiome diversity can lead to standard treatment side effects such as diarrhea, constipation, and inflammation. A healthy microbiome, supported by diet, may also influence immune responses, potentially enhancing cancer treatment efficacy and improving quality of life.

While it’s tempting to think that an alkaline diet could directly influence cancer’s growth, the body’s pH is tightly regulated through complex mechanisms. These systems maintain balance regardless of the pH of the foods we eat.

The Science of Cancer Metabolism and Acid Production

Cancer cells often undergo a unique metabolic shift known as the “Warburg effect,” in which they rely heavily on glycolysis (a sugar-metabolizing pathway) for energy, even in the presence of oxygen. (7, 8) This process produces lactic acid as a byproduct, creating an acidic microenvironment around tumor cells.

Again, this acidity is confined to the local tumor environment and does not affect overall blood or tissue pH. Here’s why this is relevant:

• Tumor Acidity is a Symptom, Not a Cause - The acidic environment is a consequence of how cancer cells metabolize glucose. (9) Attempting to change body pH through diet does not alter cancer cells' metabolism.
• Systemic pH is Unaffected by Diet: The body regulates blood pH tightly through mechanisms like respiration and kidney function, and it is unaffected by dietary intake.

Cancer patients are better served by focusing on well-rounded nutrition, hydration, and treatments that support the body’s immune system and enhance the efficacy of cancer treatments.

A balanced diet rich in nutrients, proper hydration, and strategies to support digestive health are much more effective than altering the body’s pH through alkaline food or water. Understanding how the body regulates pH helps us focus on what truly matters in cancer care - supporting the body’s natural healing processes rather than chasing myths.

So, Why Does This Myth Persist?

Several misunderstandings contribute to the persistent belief in the alkaline diet as a cancer preventative or cure.

Simplification of pH in Health Conversations:

It’s natural to assume that “acid” is harmful and “alkaline” is protective, especially with acidic byproducts linked to cancer. However, cancer’s acidic environment is a localized result of cancer metabolism rather than a reflection of whole-body pH. Additionally, promoters of the alkaline diet often use broad statements about pH without clarifying the complexities of how pH functions specifically within various body systems.

Misinterpretation of Lab-Based Studies

Some lab studies show that cancer cells grow better in acidic environments, leading to the assumption that raising the body’s pH could counteract cancer growth. However, these studies are conducted in isolated cell cultures that do not replicate the complexities of a living human system.

Research conducted in a laboratory using isolated cells (in-vitro studies) often bypasses the body's natural regulatory systems, such as metabolism, immune responses, or hormonal feedback loops. These systems work together in a living organism to maintain balance and can significantly influence how substances behave.

For example, in a petri dish, you might observe a direct effect of a substance on cells because the cells are exposed to a controlled, simplified environment. In the human body, however, that same substance must interact with enzymes, be metabolized by the liver, circulate through the bloodstream, and potentially trigger other regulatory responses. These processes can alter or even negate the effect observed in the lab.

A 2020 review of lab-based studies looking at alkaline water supplementation concluded:

“Regardless of the advancement of alkaline water by the media and sales representatives, there is no genuine research to encourage or discredit these facts and figures. This methodical survey of the literature [sic] uncovered an absence of proof … in support of alkaline water for the inception or treatment of malignancy.” (10)

Anecdotal Evidence

Positive anecdotes of patients feeling better or experiencing improvements with an alkaline diet can lend credence to the myth. However, any benefits likely stem from improved nutrition rather than a pH shift.

What the Research Says

No scientific evidence shows that alkaline diets or alkaline water directly impact cancer prevention or treatment. While certain foods can have anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects that support general health, these benefits are independent of their pH and cannot influence the internal pH environment.

Fruits and vegetables, commonly part of an alkaline diet, are associated with health benefits, such as lower inflammation and improved immune function. However, these effects relate to nutrient content (fiber, vitamins, antioxidants) rather than pH levels.

A systematic review and meta-analysis of dietary acid load (DAL) provide critical context to the discussion. While proponents suggest that consuming an alkaline diet directly prevents or treats cancer by neutralizing body acidity, research indicates that the relationship between dietary acidity and cancer is far more complex. (11)

High DAL diets, characterized by processed proteins and low fruit and vegetable intake, may promote cancer through metabolic acidosis, reduced adiponectin levels, and mineral imbalances, which affect cell growth and metastasis. However, these effects stem from specific biochemical pathways and dietary imbalances, not the direct alteration of systemic pH, which remains tightly regulated by the body. While nutritional choices rich in fruits and vegetables and low in processed foods support overall health and may reduce cancer risk, they do so by mechanisms unrelated to the simplistic alkaline-versus-acidic framework promoted by the myth.

Drinking alkaline water may be hydrating and beneficial for those with reflux disease. It may even have anti-aging properties, but research does not support its effectiveness in preventing or treating cancer. (12, 13, 14)

Real Integrative Approaches to Support Cancer Care

Rather than attempting to manipulate body pH, integrative cancer care empowers patients with evidence-based strategies that enhance overall health and quality of life. A nutrient-rich, personalized diet is foundational, emphasizing whole foods like vegetables, lean proteins, healthy fats, and antioxidant-rich options to mitigate oxidative stress and support immune function. (15)

Gut health is crucial in nutrient absorption and immunity; incorporating prebiotic and probiotic foods, staying hydrated, and consuming adequate fiber can strengthen the microbiome. For those undergoing chemotherapy or radiation, specific dietary choices can be made to support detoxification, reduce inflammation, and manage nausea, while light exercise can help combat treatment-related fatigue. (16)

Post-treatment, the focus shifts to rebuilding resilience by supporting the immune system with probiotics, protein-rich foods, and restorative practices, including quality sleep. Adequate rest, achieved through good sleep hygiene, aids recovery and mental well-being. Nutritional supplementation tailored to changing needs during and after cancer treatment can further optimize health outcomes.

While the alkaline diet may appear logical at first glance, science shows that the body’s pH is tightly regulated, unaffected by diet, and unrelated to the acidic environment surrounding tumors. Focusing on proven integrative approaches offers a more effective path to optimizing health and well-being during cancer care.

References:

1. Cooan H. Onc, H. C. M. N. F. (2022, November 22). Omega-3 Fight Cancer and Inflammation. HeatherCooan.com. Available at: https://heathercooan.com/omega-3-fight-cancer-inflammation/
2. Kellum JA. Determinants of blood pH in health and disease. Crit Care. 2000;4(1):6-14. doi: 10.1186/cc644. Epub 2000 Jan 24.
3. Shaw I, Gregory K. Acid-base balance: a review of normal physiology. BJA Educ. 2022 Oct;22(10):396-401. doi: 10.1016/j.bjae.2022.06.003. Epub 2022 Aug 18.
4. Reuss JM, Alonso-Gamo L, Garcia-Aranda M, Reuss D, Albi M, Albi B, et al. Oral Mucosa in Cancer Patients-Putting the Pieces Together: A Narrative Review and New Perspectives. Cancers (Basel). 2023 Jun 22;15(13):3295. doi: 10.3390/cancers15133295.
5. Stanforth KJ, Wilcox MD, Chater PI, Brownlee IA, Zakhour MI, Banecki K MRM, et al. Pepsin properties, structure, and its accurate measurement: a narrative review. (2022). AOE Annals of Esophagus, 5. doi: 10.21037/aoe-20-95
6. Feitelberg SP, Hogan DL, Koss MA, Isenberg JI. pH threshold for human duodenal bicarbonate secretion and diffusion of CO2. Gastroenterology. 1992 Apr;102(4 Pt 1):1252-8. PMID: 1551532.
7. Yamamura R, Inoue KY, Nishino K, Yamasaki S. Intestinal and fecal pH in human health.
   Front. Microbiomes, Sec. Host and Microbe Associations. 26 July 2023,Vol. 2. doi: 10.3389/frmbi.2023.1192316.
8. Cooan H. Onc, H. C. M. N. F. (2022, November 12). The Metabolic Theory of Cancer Reading List. HeatherCooan.com. Available at: https://heathercooan.com/metabolic-theory-of-cancer/
9. Alberghina L. The Warburg Effect Explained: Integration of Enhanced Glycolysis with Heterogeneous Mitochondria to Promote Cancer Cell Proliferation. Int J Mol Sci. 2023 Oct 31;24(21):15787. doi: 10.3390/ijms242115787.
10. Lee SH, Griffiths JR. How and Why Are Cancers Acidic? Carbonic Anhydrase IX and the Homeostatic Control of Tumour Extracellular pH. Cancers (Basel). 2020 Jun 18;12(6):1616. doi: 10.3390/cancers12061616.
11. Sonwane G, Bhagat S, Borkar V, Jain SP, Khan SL, Kale M. Pharmacological Activity Investigation of Alkaline Water – A Review. Int J Pharm Sci Rev Res. 2022;64(88-91). doi: 10.47583/ijpsrr.2020.v64i01.017.
12. Wang R, Wen ZY, Liu FH, Wei YF, Xu HL, Sun ML, et al. Association between dietary acid load and cancer risk and prognosis: An updated systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies. Front Nutr. 2022 Jul 27;9:891936. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2022.891936.
13. Chycki J, Zając T, Maszczyk A, Kurylas A. The effect of mineral-based alkaline water on hydration status and the metabolic response to short-term anaerobic exercise. Biol Sport. 2017 Sep;34(3):255-261. doi: 10.5114/biolsport.2017.66003. Epub 2017 Feb 19.
14. Koufman JA, Johnston N. Potential benefits of pH 8.8 alkaline drinking water as an adjunct in the treatment of reflux disease. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2012 Jul;121(7):431-4. doi: 10.1177/000348941212100702.
15. Logozzi M, Mizzoni D, Di Raimo R, Andreotti M, Macchia D, Spada M, Fais S. In vivo antiaging effects of alkaline water supplementation. J Enzyme Inhib Med Chem. 2020 Dec;35(1):657-664. doi: 10.1080/14756366.2020.1733547.
16. Cooan H. Onc, H. C. M. N. F. Cancer Success Stories Archives. (n.d.). HeatherCooan.com. Available at:
    https://heathercooan.com/category/success-stories/cancer-success-stories/